Venue Number 61a. Underbelly, Cowgate, 56 Cowgate (entrances on Cowgate and Victoria Street), EH1 1EG. 28 August 20:35 (1 hour). Suitability: 14+.
|Broadway Baby Rating:|
Young people are idiots. Kirshen (Last Comic Standing, Rude Tube, The Late Late Show) is 31 now, so he's as smart as it's possible to be. ‘Hugely impressive’ (Scotsman).
* * * * * (Edinburgh Evening News).
|BROADWAY BABY REVIEW|
Substance lacking Style
|Broadway Baby Rating:|
If you’d never seen Matt Kirshen before, as he begins his set you’d be forgiven for thinking you were merely watching an overly enthusiastic sound technician, such is his affably nerdish demeanour. However, one quickly realises that Kirshen is the real deal and a joke technician of the highest order. Kirshen’s great strength is his nuanced, thoughtful and near impeccable writing. He revels in leading his audience down one stream of consciousness before yanking you back to something he may have said 10 minutes earlier.
Kirshen himself describes his show as ‘50% politics, 50% embarrassment’, and applies his scimitar-sharp craft to his own rich history of humiliation, and to politics, in equal measure, blending and weaving the two themes with aplomb. While diatribes against the New Right in the US have been executed better by other comedians (largely ones with a bit more ruthless bite than Kirshen), routines about the BNP and a gig he once did in the Shropshire wildernesses are right on the money.
What prevents this from being a better show, ironically for a stand up who has trotted the globe, is a lack of charisma. While Kirshen’s material is excellent, some of its effect is lost in his bookish delivery. Indeed, sometimes Kirshen gets so excited about the upcoming gag that he seems to rush slightly, meaning that (even in a small venue like the Belly Button) some of the routine is lost. Nonetheless, Kirshen’s show is an impressive one and well worth a look.
has written 17 reviews for Broadway Baby since joining the team in 2011.
Want to add your own review?
Login above using Facebook to review this show. We really appreciate you sharing your opinions, however please make them honest and your own. That means don't review your own show, or paste in a review of your show from another site. We'll only have to delete them, and for persistent offenders we'll need to delete your listing entirely. It's ok to disagree with our reviewer's opinion, but personal attacks will be deleted. We insist on Facebook registration as a measure to limit the amount of fake reviews on Broadway Baby. Thanks for your understanding!