Reviews of Fringe Theatre Edinburgh Fringe, Brighton Fringe, Dublin Theatre Festival
Search


Options
Broadway Baby helps you choose your Fringe programme by making suggestions based on the recommendations of other users with similar tastes. You can also hook up with people on the Fringe and make your visit a whole lot more social.
Broadway Baby is the premier online website for Fringe reviews at the Edinburgh Festival


Lost Soul Music Sky
Email
Password

forgot password?
Reviews Edinburgh Fringe Edinburgh Festival Fringe

Boys Of The Empire

The (New) Play’s The Thing

Threads 3-Star Rated

Threads

(2007)
University Of Liverpool Drama Society
C Cubed. August 5-11. 14:30 (1hr)
Printer Friendly



The basic premise behind this piece is a clever one. To quote the press release, it’s “an original Shakespearean tragedy created entirely of lines from every one of the playwright's works. Seamlessly sewn together to form an exciting new tale that the Bard himself would be proud of”.

To construct a play that the world’s greatest ever wordsmith would be proud of is an impossible boast, and one this young company falls far short of. Why raise the bar so high? In actuality they have put together a very interesting piece, but King Lear it isn’t.

It takes as its starting point Jacques great aria about the seven ages of man from As You Like It. There are in fact two “mewling, puking” infants, brothers Jack and Edmund, sons of the king. The tale that is spun for us is about how they grow up, become rivals for the same girl, and their father’s throne. It all ends in murders, and tears and battles.

There’s some very good acting, especially from Daniel Kelly as Prince Edmund and Ami Sawran as the love interest, Kate. Directors Rebecca Bax and James Percy could do with some sound effects to cover the long blackouts, but keep the action tumbling along nicely. They might get their actors to be less shouty in the emotional passages, though this is preferable to not being heard, which is often the case in this difficult, sound-absorbing, soporific, black hole of theatre. Considering the whole point of the exercise here is for us to understand the words in a new context, these young actors should learn to trust them to use their own power.

Some of this is very clever, particularly when words are picked up on from different plays and resonated. However the piece does rely quite heavily on three plays – Taming Of the Shrew, King Lear and Hamlet. One of the problems for me was that sometimes the significance of the line from its original play got in the way of its function in this new one.

There is also a fair bit of miscomprehension of the original. You can’t have someone using Gertrude’s metaphor “when sorrows come they come not single spies but in battalions” when we have, in fact, only had one sorrow and therefore only one metaphorical spy. Similarly, weeping “there is special providence in the fall of a sparrow” over the body of a dead loved one is to totally misunderstand that speech, which is about fatalism, stoicism and readiness for anything life can throw at you – the opposite of grief, in fact.

The real acid test of this as a proper play is to get someone to review it that has never heard a word of Shakespeare in his or her life. Can’t we get Brian out of the big Brother House? [Robin T. Barton]

show info
Threads
University Of Liverpool Drama Society

Director:
University Of Liverpool Drama Society

Theatre:
C Venues
Aug 2-3: 14:30(1hr) £6.50(£5.50)(C £4.50) Aug 4,7-10: 14:30(1hr) £7.50(£6.50)(C £5.50) Aug 5-6: 14:30(1hr) £7.50 Aug 11: 14:30
50


top rated
The Terrible Infants
5-Star Rated
The Terrible Infants
2008
Fantastical Fairytales

The Country
4-Star Rated
The Country
2008
"As spacious as the countryside itself"

Bite-Sized: Sunday Lunch Hour Menu
4-Star Rated
Bite-Sized: Sunday Lunch Hour Menu
2008
Full of Nourishment

Red
4-Star Rated
Red
2008
Unfair to Love in War

see all reviews...

© 1999-2008 Web Editors Ltd, All Rights Reserved. Registered in England and Wales No. 62976778. VAT No. GB 913 5714 33