Reviews of Fringe Theatre Edinburgh Fringe, Brighton Fringe, Dublin Theatre Festival
Search


Options
Broadway Baby helps you choose your Fringe programme by making suggestions based on the recommendations of other users with similar tastes. You can also hook up with people on the Fringe and make your visit a whole lot more social.
Broadway Baby is the premier online website for Fringe reviews at the Edinburgh Festival


Gill Smith OCD
Email
Password

forgot password?
Reviews Edinburgh Fringe Edinburgh Festival Fringe

Dean's Ad

An intelligent musical about terrorism.

Failed States 5-Star Rated

Failed States

(2007)
1215 Productions
Pleasance Dome. 1-27 August (not 13, 20). 15:30 (1hr10)
Printer Friendly



The opening few bars of Failed States brilliantly foreshadows the musical to follow. A combination of the British and American national anthem displays both harmony and dissonance - succinctly summarising the "special" relationship our countries enjoy.

Andrew Taylor and Desmond O'Connor's musical is not just about terrorism, but also about our reaction to it. Set in a London both before and after the 7/7 attacks, the story follows Joseph (Guy Lewis), an American ex-pat air conditioning salesman who gets embroiled in a joint MI5/CIA investigation on questionably thin evidence. His girlfriend, Anya (Joanna Heap) is the daughter of Massoud (Fanos Xenofos) a naturalised British citizen born in Iran, and most defiantly patriotic. His love of Britain is such that he ultimately rejects his future son-in-law in favour of his adopted country, despite a lack of proof.

Taylor's sharply observed script has clear parallels with Kafka's The Trial, and highlights that the American response to terrorism - and their influence over Britain - has dangerous consequences for our civil liberties. A beautifully played scene between CIA agent William (Steve McNeil) and MI5 agent Frank (Marcus Ellard) reminds us that, for Britain at least, terrorism is a reality we have been dealing with for decades, not just something you should have a knee-jerk reaction to.

O'Connor's lyrics and score are sublime. Staccato rhythms throughout relentlessly underpin a style that is somewhere between Sondheim and Laurence O'Keefe. It's appropriately aggressive for the subject matter, but you'll still come out of the theatre with the melodies bouncing around in your head. This is an intelligent musical that deliberately asks questions, challenges and pokes into uncomfortable areas, but at the same time resists the temptation to descend into an incoherent polemic.

It's all delivered by a professional cast who make use of the slightly awkward cabaret space well - confidently escaping the restraints of the small stage and occasionally delivering dialogue across sections of the audience. Most of the actors also pick up an instrument to compliment the team of three musicians and build a rich tapestry of sound - unusual for a Fringe musical, budget realities being what they are. Heather Weir's exceptional arrangements make the best use of this talented bunch.

By the close, when the full company provided an impressive finale called 'Picking Up Glass', I felt I had learnt something without being preached at; but most of all I had been entertained. [Pete Shaw]

show info
Failed States
1215 Productions

Director:
Patrick Wilde

Theatre:
Pleasance
Preview Aug 1-3: 15:30(1hr 10mins) £6.00 Aug 4,7-9,14-16,21-23,27: 15:30(1hr 10mins) £8.50(£7.50) Aug 5-6: 15:30(1hr 10mins) £8.50 Aug 10
23


top rated
The Terrible Infants
5-Star Rated
The Terrible Infants
2008
Fantastical Fairytales

The Country
4-Star Rated
The Country
2008
"As spacious as the countryside itself"

Bite-Sized: Sunday Lunch Hour Menu
4-Star Rated
Bite-Sized: Sunday Lunch Hour Menu
2008
Full of Nourishment

Red
4-Star Rated
Red
2008
Unfair to Love in War

see all reviews...

© 1999-2008 Web Editors Ltd, All Rights Reserved. Registered in England and Wales No. 62976778. VAT No. GB 913 5714 33